{"version":2,"relationshipURLBase":"https://codingai-lec03.pages.dev/course/blocks/clip-spatial-counterexample.html","relationshipResolution":"Resolve relative relationship URLs against relationshipURLBase; complete records and absolute URLs are in blocks.","title":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","url":"https://codingai-lec03.pages.dev/course/blocks/clip-spatial-counterexample.html","markdown":"https://codingai-lec03.pages.dev/course/blocks/clip-spatial-counterexample.md","pages":[{"id":"reading-opening","title":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","unit":"怎样设计让两种解释产生不同预测的测试？","unitId":"relation-discriminating-tests","chapter":"III","number":1}],"aliases":[{"oldId":"b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","targetId":"b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","page":"reading-opening","operation":"move","beforeSHA256":"f807c2a84efbf8d5cdd7a53cad88962f64745a01e3a726b0dfc8e5b92bdb8355","afterSHA256":"f807c2a84efbf8d5cdd7a53cad88962f64745a01e3a726b0dfc8e5b92bdb8355","reason":"Same source body in authored semantic page"},{"oldId":"b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","targetId":"b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","page":"reading-opening","operation":"move","beforeSHA256":"13be465c8c580bec4694a72ebfe54d2bbcb7d91c0a004a320141663883e790d5","afterSHA256":"13be465c8c580bec4694a72ebfe54d2bbcb7d91c0a004a320141663883e790d5","reason":"Same source body in authored semantic page"},{"oldId":"b-fb44a199a56a197efb358c5f","targetId":"b-fb44a199a56a197efb358c5f","page":"reading-opening","operation":"move","beforeSHA256":"28bb41da5bc9194874ab9f940b25858bda9d482c631ed23c142019c0a9fcc9a3","afterSHA256":"28bb41da5bc9194874ab9f940b25858bda9d482c631ed23c142019c0a9fcc9a3","reason":"Same source body in authored semantic page"},{"oldId":"b-45df072122ca3e79c796a2bc","targetId":"b-45df072122ca3e79c796a2bc","page":"reading-opening","operation":"move","beforeSHA256":"a03704d3c05d5ec2a67c2178b051ac4fdd8b69d54e6f999b8cffb44f26c2335f","afterSHA256":"a03704d3c05d5ec2a67c2178b051ac4fdd8b69d54e6f999b8cffb44f26c2335f","reason":"Same source body in authored semantic page"},{"oldId":"b-da513bb6ebff167932467345","targetId":"b-da513bb6ebff167932467345","page":"reading-opening","operation":"move","beforeSHA256":"5bc03f71d0e73034dde1ae62b299fce1769bd31220bdeb1b8cbc64c7b96cfa93","afterSHA256":"5bc03f71d0e73034dde1ae62b299fce1769bd31220bdeb1b8cbc64c7b96cfa93","reason":"Same source body in authored semantic page"},{"oldId":"b-7542c68838116bba46bb9de2","targetId":"b-7542c68838116bba46bb9de2","page":"reading-opening","operation":"move","beforeSHA256":"f31c3699a0e1f176327e4bfaf25417790d3497042d29f37bcc4bf17f2eb09efd","afterSHA256":"f31c3699a0e1f176327e4bfaf25417790d3497042d29f37bcc4bf17f2eb09efd","reason":"Same source body in authored semantic page"},{"oldId":"b-621304c8a59d80fa170a15a9","targetId":"b-621304c8a59d80fa170a15a9","page":"reading-opening","operation":"move","beforeSHA256":"f0529d244ad53e4c6e72d06fbfd7c6c100f28b5e3c65f0f8931c111e94b9613d","afterSHA256":"f0529d244ad53e4c6e72d06fbfd7c6c100f28b5e3c65f0f8931c111e94b9613d","reason":"Same source body in authored semantic page"},{"oldId":"b-3e4c0b5619a0279ae6f265bd","targetId":"b-3e4c0b5619a0279ae6f265bd","page":"reading-opening","operation":"move","beforeSHA256":"2b9ccef7e1220e2250cceff1abd8bdd736b42f8da5a223f26b029f44b962e807","afterSHA256":"2b9ccef7e1220e2250cceff1abd8bdd736b42f8da5a223f26b029f44b962e807","reason":"Same source body in authored semantic page"}],"blocks":[{"id":"b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","type":"h1","scope":"clip-spatial-counterexample","url":"https://codingai-lec03.pages.dev/course/blocks/clip-spatial-counterexample.html#b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","content":"# 真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","sha256":"f807c2a84efbf8d5cdd7a53cad88962f64745a01e3a726b0dfc8e5b92bdb8355","chapter":{"id":"III","title":"视觉与语言"},"unit":{"id":"relation-discriminating-tests","title":"怎样设计让两种解释产生不同预测的测试？"},"page":{"id":"reading-opening","title":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","number":1},"sectionTitle":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","currentQuestion":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","sourceSlides":[],"knowledgeBlock":null,"formulas":[],"previousBlock":null,"nextBlock":"b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","prerequisites":[{"id":"b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","url":"#b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","role":"problem-context"}],"relatedBlocks":[]},{"id":"b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","type":"p","scope":"clip-spatial-counterexample","url":"https://codingai-lec03.pages.dev/course/blocks/clip-spatial-counterexample.html#b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","content":"四格的非对角条件才使两种解释分叉。逐格比较关系规则与左色规则的答案，并检查当前素材还有哪些变量共同变化。已保存的真实 CLIP 拼贴反例使用另一组输入与数值，应按各自条件解读。","sha256":"13be465c8c580bec4694a72ebfe54d2bbcb7d91c0a004a320141663883e790d5","chapter":{"id":"III","title":"视觉与语言"},"unit":{"id":"relation-discriminating-tests","title":"怎样设计让两种解释产生不同预测的测试？"},"page":{"id":"reading-opening","title":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","number":1},"sectionTitle":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","currentQuestion":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","sourceSlides":[],"knowledgeBlock":null,"formulas":[],"previousBlock":"b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","nextBlock":"b-fb44a199a56a197efb358c5f","prerequisites":[{"id":"b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","url":"#b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","role":"section-title"}],"relatedBlocks":[]},{"id":"b-fb44a199a56a197efb358c5f","type":"p","scope":"clip-spatial-counterexample","url":"https://codingai-lec03.pages.dev/course/blocks/clip-spatial-counterexample.html#b-fb44a199a56a197efb358c5f","content":"持球四格首先是一份规则预测表；它与 LAB04 另一组真实 CLIP 关系推理不是同一证据。后者使用猫和宇航员的固定拼贴，交换左右位置，比较“猫在左、宇航员在右”及其相反描述。","sha256":"28bb41da5bc9194874ab9f940b25858bda9d482c631ed23c142019c0a9fcc9a3","chapter":{"id":"III","title":"视觉与语言"},"unit":{"id":"relation-discriminating-tests","title":"怎样设计让两种解释产生不同预测的测试？"},"page":{"id":"reading-opening","title":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","number":1},"sectionTitle":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","currentQuestion":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","sourceSlides":[],"knowledgeBlock":null,"formulas":[],"previousBlock":"b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","nextBlock":"b-45df072122ca3e79c796a2bc","prerequisites":[{"id":"b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","url":"#b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","role":"section-title"},{"id":"b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","url":"#b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","role":"problem-context"}],"relatedBlocks":[]},{"id":"b-45df072122ca3e79c796a2bc","type":"p","scope":"clip-spatial-counterexample","url":"https://codingai-lec03.pages.dev/course/blocks/clip-spatial-counterexample.html#b-45df072122ca3e79c796a2bc","content":"2026-09-22 保存结果中，猫左图的两句余弦约为 0.37850、0.38184；交换后约为 0.35660、0.36301。两图都偏向“宇航员在左、猫在右”，所以第一张关系判断错误。这说明在该固定模型、拼贴与文字条件下，整体匹配没有正确区分这一次左右绑定。","sha256":"a03704d3c05d5ec2a67c2178b051ac4fdd8b69d54e6f999b8cffb44f26c2335f","chapter":{"id":"III","title":"视觉与语言"},"unit":{"id":"relation-discriminating-tests","title":"怎样设计让两种解释产生不同预测的测试？"},"page":{"id":"reading-opening","title":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","number":1},"sectionTitle":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","currentQuestion":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","sourceSlides":[],"knowledgeBlock":null,"formulas":[],"previousBlock":"b-fb44a199a56a197efb358c5f","nextBlock":"b-da513bb6ebff167932467345","prerequisites":[{"id":"b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","url":"#b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","role":"section-title"},{"id":"b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","url":"#b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","role":"problem-context"}],"relatedBlocks":[]},{"id":"b-da513bb6ebff167932467345","type":"p","scope":"clip-spatial-counterexample","url":"https://codingai-lec03.pages.dev/course/blocks/clip-spatial-counterexample.html#b-da513bb6ebff167932467345","content":"但同一模型在猫图候选分类和小图库检索中有真实成功，不能用这个失败抹去对象匹配能力。更准确的研究问题是：哪些对象和语义可以由全局表示稳定匹配，哪些细粒度关系需要更合适的空间组织、交互或训练资料？","sha256":"5bc03f71d0e73034dde1ae62b299fce1769bd31220bdeb1b8cbc64c7b96cfa93","chapter":{"id":"III","title":"视觉与语言"},"unit":{"id":"relation-discriminating-tests","title":"怎样设计让两种解释产生不同预测的测试？"},"page":{"id":"reading-opening","title":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","number":1},"sectionTitle":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","currentQuestion":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","sourceSlides":[],"knowledgeBlock":null,"formulas":[],"previousBlock":"b-45df072122ca3e79c796a2bc","nextBlock":"b-7542c68838116bba46bb9de2","prerequisites":[{"id":"b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","url":"#b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","role":"section-title"},{"id":"b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","url":"#b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","role":"problem-context"}],"relatedBlocks":[]},{"id":"b-7542c68838116bba46bb9de2","type":"p","scope":"clip-spatial-counterexample","url":"https://codingai-lec03.pages.dev/course/blocks/clip-spatial-counterexample.html#b-7542c68838116bba46bb9de2","content":"LAB12 的局部加权规则提供另一种解释路径：查询改变了猫/宇航员区域权重，却因汇总公式忽略坐标而对交换左右严格不敏感。这个失败来自可指出的结构对称性。它帮助区分“区域更多”与“关系已经被表达”，再自然接入 P63 的定位任务。以上均为已有历史记录，本轮没有重跑或扩大结论。","sha256":"f31c3699a0e1f176327e4bfaf25417790d3497042d29f37bcc4bf17f2eb09efd","chapter":{"id":"III","title":"视觉与语言"},"unit":{"id":"relation-discriminating-tests","title":"怎样设计让两种解释产生不同预测的测试？"},"page":{"id":"reading-opening","title":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","number":1},"sectionTitle":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","currentQuestion":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","sourceSlides":[],"knowledgeBlock":null,"formulas":[],"previousBlock":"b-da513bb6ebff167932467345","nextBlock":"b-621304c8a59d80fa170a15a9","prerequisites":[{"id":"b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","url":"#b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","role":"section-title"},{"id":"b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","url":"#b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","role":"problem-context"}],"relatedBlocks":[]},{"id":"b-621304c8a59d80fa170a15a9","type":"p","scope":"clip-spatial-counterexample","url":"https://codingai-lec03.pages.dev/course/blocks/clip-spatial-counterexample.html#b-621304c8a59d80fa170a15a9","content":"LAB04 的旧四幅持球插图也确实在 2026-09-22 做过真实 CLIP 编码，保存结果为四例中三例正确；它并非从未运行过模型。但那四幅旧输入与 v18 当前同源编辑/镜像的 A–D 底图不一致，且旧插图存在背景和姿态差异。旧分数不能贴到当前四格，也不能把 3/4 当成单变量因果结论。回链阅读时要连同原图片、候选和输入哈希一起核对。","sha256":"f0529d244ad53e4c6e72d06fbfd7c6c100f28b5e3c65f0f8931c111e94b9613d","chapter":{"id":"III","title":"视觉与语言"},"unit":{"id":"relation-discriminating-tests","title":"怎样设计让两种解释产生不同预测的测试？"},"page":{"id":"reading-opening","title":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","number":1},"sectionTitle":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","currentQuestion":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","sourceSlides":[],"knowledgeBlock":null,"formulas":[],"previousBlock":"b-7542c68838116bba46bb9de2","nextBlock":"b-3e4c0b5619a0279ae6f265bd","prerequisites":[{"id":"b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","url":"#b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","role":"section-title"},{"id":"b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","url":"#b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","role":"problem-context"}],"relatedBlocks":[]},{"id":"b-3e4c0b5619a0279ae6f265bd","type":"h2","scope":"clip-spatial-counterexample","url":"https://codingai-lec03.pages.dev/course/blocks/clip-spatial-counterexample.html#b-3e4c0b5619a0279ae6f265bd","content":"## 继续阅读与实验","sha256":"2b9ccef7e1220e2250cceff1abd8bdd736b42f8da5a223f26b029f44b962e807","chapter":{"id":"III","title":"视觉与语言"},"unit":{"id":"relation-discriminating-tests","title":"怎样设计让两种解释产生不同预测的测试？"},"page":{"id":"reading-opening","title":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","number":1},"sectionTitle":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","currentQuestion":"真实 CLIP 关系反例与规则四格，应分开读","sourceSlides":[],"knowledgeBlock":null,"formulas":[],"previousBlock":"b-621304c8a59d80fa170a15a9","nextBlock":null,"prerequisites":[{"id":"b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","url":"#b-e9028721d379efdd6e4cec49","role":"section-title"},{"id":"b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","url":"#b-12323b2013dbf053cf9a5faf","role":"problem-context"}],"relatedBlocks":[]}]}